These 12 historical phantoms—our mystery identities—drift through archives like cursed code, leaving behind tantalizing breadcrumbs and nightmares in equal measure.
sponsored ad
From amnesiac teachers trapped in state wards to masked men who laughed at kings, each enigma festers with unanswered questions, dark theories, and a flair for the grotesque. Dive into these cryptic corridors of the past and vote for the puzzle that keeps you up at night.
1. Amnesia Patient Mary Doefour: A Mystery Identity Drowned in Shock Therapy
They called her Mary Doefour, but that was as hollow as the padded walls of Queenwood East Nursing Home where she died in March 1978. Beaten, pregnant, and found wandering a roadside in Illinois decades earlier, this mystery identity couldn’t recall a scrap of her life—only that she’d once taught school.
sponsored ad
Shock therapy bleached her memories until, for 50 years, no one questioned her lack of name or kin. A lone reporter’s dusty 14-page exposé nearly cracked the case—whispers of an Iowa teacher named Anna Myrle Sizer—yet the final answer slipped away like a bad dream. mystery identities
2. The $200,000 Ghost: D.B. Cooper’s Vanishing Ransom and Mystery Identities
November 24, 1971: a suited phantom known as “D.B. Cooper” hijacks Flight 305, pockets $200,000 in twenties, and tumbles into the rainy void over Washington. His fate? An eternal question, a wilderness without body or gear.
In 1980, $6,000 of his ransom washed ashore on the Columbia’s banks, yet the rest—and the man behind the alias—remain spectral footnotes in FBI files. Conspiracy buffs still chase this mystery identity, lured by rumors of mislaid loot and forensic missteps.
3. Tiananmen’s Silent Rebel: Tank Man’s Mystery Identity
June 5, 1989: one unarmed figure blocks a column of tanks, shopping bags in hand, and the world pauses. No matter how many decades pass, his mystery identity endures.
Was he a student named Wang Weilin, executed days later? Or did he melt into the shadows, protected by silence? China’s censorship apparatus erased him from domestic memory, yet globally he stands immortal—an unintended martyr in the pantheon of mystery identities.
4. Ciphered in Blood: The Zodiac Killer and Unbroken Mystery Identities
Bay Area, late 1960s: unspeakable murders and taunting letters sealed in cryptograms. One cipher cracked, many remain unsolved, and the killer’s true name is as elusive as a midnight whisper.
sponsored ad
Various suspects—from Air Force pilots to posh librarians—vie for infamy, but no DNA or decoding has delivered a final verdict. The Zodiac lurks still in the shadows of mystery identities, grinning behind his coded threats.
5. The Drowned Mona Lisa’s Mask: An Unfinished Mystery Identity
“L’Inconnue de la Seine,” the pale face of a drowned teenager immortalized in plaster—all smiles and closed eyes. Yet did she actually drown? Her face was too flawless; theories range from high-fashion model to murdered Hungarian actress. Centuries later, her visage trains CPR mannequins worldwide, teaching life with the face of a probable corpse. This mystery identity crept from Seine’s dark currents into every rescue course.
6. Velvet vs. Iron: The Man in the Iron Mask’s Dual Mystery Identities
Not iron at all but velvet, the faceless prisoner of Louis XIV ignited legends of royal conspiracies. Two suspects—Ercole Matthiole and Eustache Dauger—wear the mask of possibility, each a contender in the unsolvable drama of mystery identities. One perished too soon, the other vanished under a name as dubious as the mask he wore. The court’s hush remains, as thick as the prison stone.
7. The Babushka Lady: Kennedy’s Unfilmed Mystery Identity
Dallas, 1963: amid the chaos, a woman in a headscarf films the assassination, then vaporizes into the crowd. FBI files balloon with half-hearted leads and phony claimants, but the real Babushka Lady slipped through their claws. Some whisper she was a Russian agent; others claim she joined the Secret Service. To this day, her mystery identity is nothing but grainy frames and unanswered questions.
8. Jack the Ripper’s Scarf DNA: A Grim Hope for Mystery Identities
1888, Whitechapel’s fog-soaked alleys: a shawl stained with crime, a genealogist’s mtDNA match to Aaron Kosminski—yet the scientific world snarls at the methodology. Over a century later, amateur detectives and conspiracy theorists still wield PCR machines in pubs, hoping to trap the ghost of Jack. His mystery identity flickers between fact, fiction, and the stains on a shawl.
9. The Green Children of Woolpit: Otherworldly Mystery Identities
1150, Suffolk: two green-skinned children emerge gibbering from underground tunnels, babbling of St. Martin’s realm. Diet cures the hue, but the questions linger—were they malnourished or martians? Perhaps refugees or mythic emissaries. Their mystery identities seep into medieval folklore, an unsolved riddle that makes modern internet sleuths green with envy.
10. L.W. Wright: NASCAR’s Phantom Racer and Financial Mystery Identity
Talladega, 1982: a rookie named L.W. Wright speeds into the Winston 500 on borrowed sponsorship and bounced checks. Engine blown, identity blown away—today, no Spec sheet or birth certificate matches the name. He’s the ultimate con-driver, a mystery identity that outran both rivals and creditors.
11. The Immortal Count of Saint-Germain: Alchemy’s Eternal Mystery Identity
18th-century salons buzzed with wonder at the ageless Count of Saint-Germain—violin virtuoso, painter, alchemist… perhaps he never revealed his real name because he never aged. Portuguese Jew, spy, twin of Louis XIV? None of the theories stick to this wandering enigma. His tombstone reads death in 1784, but his mystery identity refuses burial.
12. Banksy: Street Art’s Viral Mystery Identity
Since the 1990s, stencils dripping with satire have surfaced from Bristol to Bethlehem, each one signed by an invisible hand. Rumored to be Robin Gunningham or Massive Attack’s Robert Del Naja, Banksy floats above the law, above fame, cloaked in cans of spray paint and whispered theories. His mystery identity remains the ultimate protest—an unclaimed throne in the kingdom of cursed internet legends.
sponsored ad
